By Syril Diesta
Can anyone own a letter of the alphabet? At first glance, the answer seems obvious. But trademark law rarely asks whether someone owns a letter in the abstract. The harder question is whether the way that letter is presented has become distinctive enough that another trader’s version comes too close.
In a notable decision reaffirming the application of the Dominancy Test, the Philippine Supreme Court, in Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, LLC v. Oceana Empire Limited [G.R. Nos. 262551, 266971, and 275314, January 28, 2026], held that the Dominancy Test requires courts to give greater weight to the main, essential, and dominant features of a mark, rather than allowing minor differences to drive the analysis. Writing for the Court’s First Division, Associate Justice Ramon Paul L. Hernando ruled in favour of Starwood, the company behind the W Hotels brand.
The dispute therefore became about much more than one letter. It asked how far a trademark owner’s protection can extend when the shared feature is simple, but its visual presentation is not.
The Battle Over "W"
In 2015, Oceanic Empire Limited (“Oceanic”) filed applications for registration of the trademarks (1) W GLOBALCENTER; (2) W FIFTHAVENUE; and (3) W TOWER with the Intellectual Property Office of the Philippines (“IPOPHL”) in relation to real estate affairs services in Class 36. W TOWER proceeded to registration, while the other two applications remained pending.
Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, LLC (“Starwood”) opposed W GLOBALCENTER and W FIFTHAVENUE, and sought cancellation of W TOWER. Starwood contended that Oceanic’s marks were confusingly similar to its registered “W” marks, including its stylised W HOTELS mark (reproduced below), covering, among others, hotel and motel services, and building construction and installation services in Classes 37, 41 and 43. Starwood claimed that Oceanic was riding on Starwood’s goodwill and risked confusing the purchasing public.
The letter “W” divided the decision-makers below. The Director of IPOPHL’s Bureau of Legal Affairs (“IPO-BLA Director”) considered the stylised W the dominant feature and found confusion likely. The IPO Director General disagreed, reasoning that no one could exclusively appropriate a letter of the alphabet and that the differences in font, services and purchasing circumstances reduced the likelihood of confusion. The Court of Appeals likewise ruled in Oceanic’s favour.
The Supreme Court took the opposite view. It granted Starwood’s petitions, reversed the Court of Appeals, directed the denial of Oceanic’s applications for W GLOBALCENTER and W FIFTHAVENUE, and ordered the cancellation of the W TOWER registration.
Protect your brand across classes and borders
It Was Never Just the Letter
Invoking Kolin Electronics Co., Inc. v. Kolin Philippines International, Inc., 896 Phil. 190, 215 (2021), the Supreme Court reaffirmed that the Dominancy Test is the controlling standard in determining the resemblance between marks. Similarity does not require identity; a colourable imitation may be sufficient where the form, wording, sound, meaning, arrangement or overall appearance is likely to mislead an average buyer.
Crucially, the Court drew a clear line between Starwood’s marks. Viewed as a plain word mark, “W” was simply a standalone letter of the alphabet. With many other registrations adopting the letter W in various styles and classes, the word mark alone was not distinctive enough to identify Starwood as its single source. Starwood’s case succeeded instead on its stylised W HOTELS mark.
Applying the Dominancy Test to that stylised mark, the Court found, as the IPO-BLA Director had, that the bold, uppercase, sans-serif stylised W remained the dominant or prevalent feature of both parties’ marks.
The additional words, “TOWER”, “FIFTHAVENUE” and “GLOBALCENTER” did not save Oceanic. The emphasis was on the bold W, while the additional wording appeared thinner and visually subordinate. The Court also regarded that wording as generic or descriptive rather than sufficiently distinctive in its own right: “TOWER” names a type of building, while “FIFTHAVENUE” and “GLOBALCENTER” point to a location or commercial purpose. Tellingly, Oceanic had itself disclaimed exclusive rights over “GLOBALCENTER” during the registration process, undermining its argument that the word set its mark apart.
This distinction matters. Starwood did not acquire a monopoly over the alphabet. What it successfully protected was the commercial impression created by its particular stylised W.
Put differently, adding more words does not necessarily create more distance if consumers still remember the same dominant feature
Different Classes, Same Commercial Neighbourhood
Oceanic’s services were classified under Class 36 for real estate affairs, while Starwood’s registrations extended across different classes, including hotel and related services. At first sight, this appears to favour coexistence. But class numbers organise trademarks; they do not necessarily organise commercial reality.
The Supreme Court reiterated that the Nice Classification is not controlling in determining whether goods or services are related. Substantive trademark rights should not turn on a classification system whose function is principally administrative.
Instead, the Court looked at the businesses themselves. Both involved the use and occupation of real property, appealed to premium market segments and placed significant value on the location and aesthetic appeal of their buildings. Both parties also prominently displayed the stylised W on building façades, and Oceanic at times used the W on its own, or with the additional words placed beneath it, mirroring Starwood’s own layout.
That raises a practical question for brand owners: Are your businesses really unrelated simply because they sit in different Nice classes?
The answer may increasingly be no.
Does a High Price Tag Prevent Confusion?
Another interesting aspect of the case concerned the sophistication of purchasers. Real estate and luxury hospitality services are not impulse purchases. The lower tribunals placed weight on the assumption that consumers spending substantial sums would exercise greater care.
The Supreme Court nevertheless found that even ordinarily intelligent and sophisticated buyers could still assume a commercial connection between the parties.
That is an important distinction. Consumer sophistication may reduce confusion over what is being purchased, but it does not necessarily eliminate confusion over who stands behind it, whether the businesses are affiliated, or whether one represents a natural extension of the other.
The Modern Brand Does Not Stay in its Lane
Starwood did not have a physical hotel operating in the Philippines. That did not end the inquiry.
The Court observed that through the cybermarketplace, Filipino consumers could become familiar with Starwood’s international hotels, access and book them online, and avail themselves of its services abroad. This is consistent with the Court’s earlier ruling in W Land Holdings, Inc. v. Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide, Inc. (G.R. No. 222366, December 4, 2017), where Starwood’s “W” registration survived a non-use cancellation action on the strength of its interactive hotel booking website.
A brand, in other words, no longer needs bricks and mortar in a jurisdiction to occupy space in the consumer’s mind.
The Court also recognised that trademark protection may extend into areas of normal potential business expansion. Hospitality, property, residential developments and lifestyle branding increasingly overlap; hotel brands today frequently extend beyond hotel rooms into branded residences, commercial spaces and property management.
That commercial reality mattered.
Three Key Takeaways
- Protect the presentation, not just the letter. Starwood’s plain “W” word mark did not carry the day, but its stylised W HOTELS mark did. A simple element can still be legally powerful when its stylisation becomes the feature consumers remember most. Brand owners relying on letters, monograms or short marks should register their stylised and logo versions alongside their word marks.
- Descriptive add-ons and different classes are not safe harbours. Adding generic or descriptive words, particularly words an applicant has disclaimed, will not create distance if the dominant feature stays the same. Likewise, different Nice classes offer no automatic protection where the underlying businesses, market positioning or channels of trade overlap.
- Clear a new mark against where brands are heading and how they are used. Trademark clearance should look beyond the earlier brand’s immediate line of business and consider where consumers might reasonably expect it to expand next, including through online channels and across borders. It should also account for how marks appear in the real world, from signage to layout, because even sophisticated buyers may assume an affiliation that does not exist.
Conclusion
The Supreme Court’s decision does not mean that Starwood owns the letter “W”. Far from it. What it demonstrates is that trademark law protects more than letters and words viewed in isolation. It protects the commercial impression they create in the minds of consumers.
For applicants, the lesson is equally important. Adding descriptive words, changing classes or targeting sophisticated purchasers may not create sufficient distance where the feature consumers notice first and remember longest remains uncomfortably close to an earlier mark.
In an era where businesses increasingly cross the boundaries between hospitality, property and lifestyle, trademark analysis must follow commercial reality rather than administrative labels.
And sometimes, an entire trademark dispute can turn on a single letter.
For further questions or advice on how this ruling may affect your trademark applications or intellectual property portfolio, please contact us at kass@kass.asia.