Industry: Consumer Goods
Matter Type: Patent Litigation (Infringement & Invalidation Analysis)
Status: Ongoing
Background and Challenge
A consumer goods manufacturer received a legal notice alleging infringement of a third party’s Malaysian Utility Innovation Certificate (UIC). The allegation posed significant commercial and legal risks, requiring immediate expert intervention to assess the validity of the claim and formulate an effective defense strategy.
Key Takeaways
- The client faced a significant infringement allegation involving a Malaysian Utility Innovation Certificate, requiring immediate technical and legal assessment to mitigate commercial and legal risks.
- KASS International’s dual-track approach provided a clear understanding of both potential product overlap with the UIC claims and the underlying weaknesses in the patent’s novelty and inventive step.
- The combined infringement and validity analyses enabled the client to formulate a strong defensive position and identify strategic grounds for counteraction.
- Based on detailed technical evidence and litigation-focused guidance, the client initiated invalidation proceedings, shifting the momentum of the dispute in their favor.
- The opponent’s decision not to appeal confirms a decisive victory for the client and underscores KASS International’s commitment to defending brand rights against powerful industry challengers.
Book a Trademark Strategy Consultation
Book a Trademark Strategy Consultation
Pain Points
Threat to brand identity and market positioning
Potential loss of trademark rights and commercial investment
Facing well-resourced opposition from established brand
Extended legal uncertainty affecting business planning
KASS International’s Approach
We mounted a comprehensive defense strategy:
Counter Statement Filing: Crafted detailed legal response refuting similarity claims with technical trademark analysis
Evidence Compilation: Prepared meticulous Statutory Declaration establishing the client’s trademark rights and distinctiveness
Legal Advocacy: Developed persuasive Written Submission demonstrating lack of confusing similarity through comparative analysis
Resolution Strategy
Throughout the 12-year legal battle, KASS International provided:
Consistent strategic guidance and case management
Technical expertise in trademark law and practice
Robust documentation and evidence preparation
Coordination with legal proceedings
Key Outcomes
After persistent advocacy, the decision was rendered entirely in our client’s favor. Significantly, the opponent chose not to appeal, confirming the strength of our arguments and securing our client’s trademark rights permanently.
This victory demonstrates KASS International’s tenacity in protecting clients’ brand assets, even against major industry players, through meticulous preparation and strategic legal advocacy.
Pain Points
Potential exposure to infringement liability and damages
Risk of injunctive relief affecting product distribution
Uncertainty regarding the strength of the third party’s patent rights
Need for rapid, technically sound legal strategy
KASS International’s Approach
Our team deployed a comprehensive two-pronged litigation support strategy:
Infringement Assessment: We conducted detailed technical analysis comparing the client’s product features against the UIC claims, identifying areas of potential overlap and providing clarity on infringement risk.
Validity Analysis: In parallel, we performed rigorous patent invalidation research, examining the UIC’s novelty and inventive step from both technical and legal perspectives, uncovering potential grounds for challenging the patent’s validity.
Resolution Strategy
Armed with our detailed findings, we equipped the client and their legal counsel with:
Technical evidence supporting invalidation proceedings
Strategic recommendations for defensive countermeasures
Expert analysis to inform litigation strategy
The client successfully initiated invalidation proceedings as a strategic response, shifting the dispute dynamics in their favor. The matter is proceeding to formal court proceedings with the client in a strengthened position.
Key Outcomes
This case demonstrates KASS International’s capability in managing high-stakes IP disputes by combining technical expertise, legal insight, and commercial awareness to protect our clients’ business interests in contentious environments.